Sunday Summer Playlist Turned Mixtape

by Scott H. Payne on July 19, 2009

I don’t know how it is in your neck of the woods, but around here the summer weather has finally hit and with a vengeance. As I puttered around the condo today doing things with which I’m unused to having to deal like replacing shower curtain rods and repairing closet handles — all of which is par for the course when you own your home, but home ownership is still a new animal for me — I decided I needed a decidedly summer playlist to go with my decidedly summer beer.

The process I followed was a simple one: I scrolled through my music collection in iTunes and pulled those songs that struck me as summer tunes into a playlist. Each artist was allowed only one entry and then I placed the list on shuffle and let ‘er fly. Below are the results (in shuffled order):

  1. Phantom Limb – The Shins
  2. Happy Phantom – Tori Amos
  3. Rivers Of Babylon – Sublime
  4. Scar Tissue – Red Hot Chili Peppers
  5. Saving Grace – Tom Petty
  6. Speak to me (Breathe) – Pink Floyd
  7. Human Behavior  – Björk
  8. Oliver’s Army  – Elvis Costello
  9. Rosalita (Come Out Tonight) – Bruce Springsteen
  10. Summer Of ’69  – Bryan Adams
  11. Dreams – The Cranberries
  12. What’s The Frequency, Kenneth? – R.E.M.
  13. Tangled Up in Blue  – Bob Dylan
  14. Strong Enough – Sheryl Crow
  15. Lions Of The Kalahari – Sam Roberts
  16. The Boxer – Simon & Garfunkel
  17. Let’s Stay Together – Al Green
  18. Roadhouse Blues – The Doors
  19. San Francisco – Brett Dennen
  20. Elevation – U2
  21. Brian Wilson – Barenaked Ladies
  22. Viva la Vida – Coldplay
  23. Can You Feel It – Michael Jackson
  24. Tonight, Tonight – Smashing Pumpkins
  25. Bold As Love – John Mayer
  26. I’ll Take Care Of You / It’s A Man’s, Man’s, Man’s World – Van Morrison
  27. I Did It – Dave Matthews Band
  28. Under My Thumb – Rolling Stones
  29. The Good Times Are Killing Me – Modest Mouse
  30. Traveling Riverside Blues – Led Zeppelin
  31. You Can Call Me Al – Paul Simon
  32. Island In The Sun – Weezer
  33. Any Road – George Harrison
  34. I Can’t Stay – The Killers
  35. 1 2 3 4  – Feist
  36. Sure Shot – Beastie Boys
  37. If I Ever Lose My Faith In You – Sting
  38. Sleeping Sickness – City And Colour
  39. Bandages – Hot Hot Heat
  40. Angel – Sarah McLachlan
  41. Friend Of The Devil – Counting Crows
  42. My Doorbell – The White Stripes
  43. Criminal – Fiona Apple
  44. Mr. Wendal -Arrested Development
  45. Wake Up – The Arcade Fire
  46. Times Like These – Jack Johnson
  47. Flightless Bird, American Mouth – Iron & Wine
  48. Old Shoes (& Picture Postcards) -Tom Waits
  49. Born Losers – Matthew Good
  50. Mouthful Of Cavities – Blind Melon
  51. Lets Stay Engaged – The Tragically Hip
  52. I Try – Macy Gray
  53. Honey – Moby
  54. Kids – MGMT
  55. Sugar, We’re Goin’ Down – Fall Out Boy
  56. Hail, Hail – Pearl Jam
  57. Exit Music (For A Film) – Radiohead
  58. Say Hello, Wave Goodbye  – David Gray
  59. July, July! – The Decemberists
  60. Sunken Waltz – Calexico
  61. Best Of You – Foo Fighters
  62. Short Skirt Long Jacket – Cake
  63. Let’s Go Crazy – Prince
  64. Hook – Blues Traveler
  65. My Sweet Love  – John Mellencamp
  66. Remedy – The Black Crowes
  67. One Man Army – Our Lady Peace
  68. Nicotina (She’s All That) – Big Sugar

Some of the selections are obvious, others less so. Some selections will make heads shake, but I was happy to hear every one today. Feel free to offer your own suggestions for entries or take me to task for some selections you think are ridiculous, debating music would be a nice change from political wrangling.

Update: the title of this post has been changed because the contents’ un-mixtape-edness has offended the purists. Their offense is not without merit and so later today I will attempt to mixtape-ify the list by trimming it into a sixty minute selection with intentional ordering.

Explanation and Mixtape-ification

So fair call in saying that the selection above is too long to be properly called a mixtape, the selection was built for length. I basically wanted a playlist that would keep going for an extended period of time while I got everything I needed to accomplish done. This, I think, is the bonus of the playlist and iTunes/Windows Media Player/whatever you happen to use. Sure, on the face of it a playlist lacks the depth of a good mixtape (or CD), but the breadth it brings to the table is indespensible sometimes. Plus, it would be interesting to see someone try to craft a sixty-plus song playlist as carefully as they would a sixty-minute mixtape. That kind of length would give you a real run for your money in terms of coming up with, exploring and meshing together subtle themes.

That is not what I did with the above, it was a relatively quick and dirty job that I threw together for function and then decided to share. But the process of trimming it down and ordering it has been interesting after the fact and I kind of dig that you get to see what I started with and where I wound up.

Without all the songs here to accurately gauge for time, I decided to give myself fifteen tracks at an average of four minutes a track (some are more, some are less — it should average out roughly). And, of course, I only used what was originally in the list. As a qualifier, let me say that I don’t make any claims about this list’s definitiveness. And Will should be happy to see that Fall Out Boy did not make the cut (though I considered gaming the process to keep it on just to see if it would cause any prominent veins to burst).

The following would be my album art (via Flickere flyzipper)

Cover

The title would be: Tanqueray and Tall Tales – A Belly Dancer’s Delight.

And without further ado,

  1. San Francisco – Brett Dennen
  2. Born Losers – Matthew Good
  3. Hook – Blues Traveler
  4. Kids – MGMT
  5. 1 2 3 4  – Feist
  6. Friend Of The Devil – Counting Crows
  7. Sunken Waltz – Calexico
  8. Rosalita (Come Out Tonight) – Bruce Springsteen
  9. I Did It – Dave Matthews Band
  10. Any Road – George Harrison
  11. Sleeping Sickness – City And Colour
  12. Lions Of The Kalahari – Sam Roberts
  13. Strong Enough – Sheryl Crow
  14. Flightless Bird, American Mouth – Iron & Wine
  15. Rivers Of Babylon – Sublime

{ 17 comments }

1 Will July 19, 2009 at 9:53 pm

A Fall Out Boy endorsement?!?!?! This is a serious breach of League protocol.

2 Scott H. Payne July 19, 2009 at 10:11 pm

I knew that one was going to get somebody. Don’t just squawk, Will, state yr case and I’ll respond in kind.

3 Will July 20, 2009 at 6:46 am
4 Scott H. Payne July 20, 2009 at 7:01 am

Given the level of debate that goes on over at YouTube, I think you’ll understand when I say I have a hard time taking any argument that rests its premise on one of their videos with much more than a grain of seriousness. Your argument is that the lyrics are hard to understand, I take it?

5 greginak July 20, 2009 at 12:20 am

Well sunken waltz is one of the greatest songs in the world. But there are so many other good Calexico songs….grrrr. Maybe tulsa telephone book.

I don’t think we can adequately pick apart and criticize your selections, intelligence, taste and breath without knowing your rationale for each song.

Except for arcade fire who are outrageously over rated.

6 Jaybird July 20, 2009 at 7:56 am

If you can make it to the end of Wake Up without crying, you are dead inside.

7 Scott H. Payne July 20, 2009 at 8:02 am

Heh. Well played.

8 William Brafford July 20, 2009 at 5:29 am

I saw “mixtape” in your title, but then when I saw that you meant “playlist” I was slightly disappointed. Here’s a few things I like about tapes or even CDs as opposed to playlists:

1. Physical limits. 30 or 45 minutes a side for a tape, 80-ish minutes for a CD. You’ve got to leave off some of those tracks.
2. Order matters. Sure, you can put a CD on shuffle, but for tapes or CDs there’s generally a problem of balance. The order of a playlist is subject to change at any moment.
3. Packaging. Can you personalize a playlist’s art?
4. Physical endurance. Finding old mixes from years ago is always an interesting experience.

I realize that none of this is important. But I do think a trimmed list communicates more about you really think constitutes good summer music, since each choice matters more.

9 Jaybird July 20, 2009 at 7:37 am

Word.

Back in my day, you agonized over every song in those 30-minutes-per-side. You had to deal with the “do I talk between songs or not?” issues.

10 Bob July 20, 2009 at 5:40 am

Summer beer for you, gin and tonic for me. So, The India Song – Big Star.

Or, Thirteen – Big Star.

11 Will July 20, 2009 at 6:41 am

Both excellent choices, Bob.

12 Bob July 20, 2009 at 6:51 am

Yeah, you can’t beat gin and tonic.

13 BCChase July 20, 2009 at 10:27 am

“Take It Easy” by the Eagles strikes me as a quintessential summer song.

14 greginak July 20, 2009 at 10:34 am

But it was fatally overplayed at least 20 years ago.

15 Scott H. Payne July 20, 2009 at 11:38 am

This is true of most Eagles songs, yes? To avoid it, I recommend the use of the Gypsy Kings cover of Hotel California.

16 E.D. Kain July 20, 2009 at 12:32 pm

Mouthful of Cavities is an amazing song but I wouldn’t put it in the summer listening category. Too bleak.

17 Scott H. Payne July 20, 2009 at 12:37 pm

Ah, depends on yr summers. Some would say that bleak is to summer as jam is to peanut butter.

Comments on this entry are closed.