Georgetown University’s Patrick J. Deneen opens this month’s Cato Unbound talking about one of our frequent conversation topics, Phillip Blond and his Red Tory synthesis:
[L]iberal anthropology… underlies both the Left’s infatuation with the State as an agent of liberation, as well as the Right’s embrace of the Market as the primary engine of human liberty. While seemingly opposed, both agents are understood to derive from, and ultimately support, the maintenance of the autonomous, freely willing self. Both are curiously anti-social entities, relying on impersonal mechanisms for the supply of human goods. Both ask little of individuals by way of actual concern for, or deep involvement with, the lives and fates of others. Our relationships, either through the State and the Market, are rendered abstract and theoretical, with each serving respectively as the impersonal replacement for actual human relations and commitments. Each relieves selves of the burdens and obligations of care, and instead derives from an understanding of polity and society in which the self can be only truly liberated when relations are rendered fungible, voluntary and contingent.
As many of you already know, I can’t say that I fully agree with the diagnosis, but I’m not an active participant in the discussion. At the moment I’m just a facilitator. Please do read the whole thing, though, and stop by again for future installments of what’s likely to be a very interesting and wide-ranging discussion.
Will Truman 
Patrick Cahalan 
Cornelius 
wardsmith 
Tod Kelly 
Tom Van Dyke 
Murali 
James Hanley 
Borat: “I do a picture, only small, of the Tishnik Masacre. Where many Uzbeks…crushed!”
Kindly Gray Hippie: “How did you feel when you drew this?”
Borat: “Very proud!”.
KGH: “I’m just listening with sadness…a little sadness for your people…?”
Borat: “Yes…no, it is not sad. It is us who do the kill!”
When in doubt,
{ 4 comments }
I’m telling all my friends I came up with this topic, even if that’s not *strictly* true.
@Will, Props for another great topic/selection of contributors, by the way.
@Will,
Thanks!
the Left’s infatuation with the State as an agent of liberation
Takes a real leap of faith to see an entity that claims a monopoly of violence as an agent of liberation. Mind you I guess States have liberated hundreds of millions from the burden of living.
Comments on this entry are closed.