Ethan Gach

Post image for The Oatmeal isn’t God and Alex Knapp isn’t the Devil

The Oatmeal published this, Alex Knapp took The Oatmeal to task, and The Oatmeal subsequently responded with a defense of the earlier comic.

Some further tweets and hundreds of thousands of page views later here we are. Freddie calls the Oatmeal’s response shitty, Oatmeal acolytes call the Knapp piece refuted, and oh, by the way, this all centers around Tesla, Edison, and one of the Internet’s favorite past times: reverse idolatry. You thought who you worshipped was worth worshipping, but really this other person is much, much better, and oh aren’t we kind of cool because we’ve got Tesla tattoos on our bellies and the rest of you hillbillies are still talking about Edison and light bulbs. You know how these things go.

And so I was inspired to enter into the fray like any good blogger and post some dribble that’s of little consequence and offers even less in the way of additional nuance. Yes, I’ll tell you up front: there is nothing unusually insightful to follow. The paragraphs below are neither pregnant with discerning analysis nor especially clever or entertainingly caustic. Instead, this post is platonically ideal in its ambition, which is, namely, to amuse myself, and perhaps two or three other people. Continue reading this post…

{ 14 comments }

Post image for How The Avengers Succeeds

“They’re a mash-up; they’re insane,” Whedon says. “But the beauty of that is as exciting as the problem of that is daunting.”

Marvel’s The Avengers is an impressive monster. A juggernaut at the box office, Joss Whedon’s film smashed the competition in Hulk fashion garnering a cool $38 million more in its opening weekend than its nearest rival: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2.

However, it does seem like these records are being surpassed all the time now. Indeed, last weekend’s usurper comes out only a year after the former champion was crowned, and the Dark Knight Rises, set to release this upcoming July, could edge past both of them.

But The Avengers is more than just a 21st century loom wheel upon which Whedon has been hard at work spinning gold. It’s also the product of a comic book culture that’s been appropriated, remade, and resold to a mainstream audience that had all but forgotten about it. Continue reading this post…

{ 86 comments }

http://ordinary-gentlemen.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/050211-wh-binladen-800.jpg

Andrew Sullivan wants Obamaites to more aggressively tout the President’s foreign policy achievements:

“I think the Obamaites need to be more aggressive in foreign policy arguments. Obama ended one war in Iraq, dispatched Osama bin Laden and Muammar Qaddafi without a single US casualty, re-set relations with Russia, brought unprecedentedly united international pressure against Iran’s nuclear bomb potential, wiped out much of al Qaeda’s mid-level leadership in Afghanistan and Pakistan, and presided over democratic revolutions in Iran, Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, and Bahrain. He restored this country’s moral credibility after the dark period of Nazi-style interrogation under Cheney, Bush and Rumsfeld.”

The above resume of accomplishments is in no small part why Peter Bergen calls our 44th President the “Warrior in Chief.” Continue reading this post…

{ 95 comments }

At Rortybomb (which has migrated to Next New Deal), Mike Konczal takes arguments against lower rates on student loans to task. My only question is this: Are taxes owed to the U.S. government a kind of debt? Continue reading this post…

{ 21 comments }

Post image for “Girls be making HBO shows, am I right?”

This gives a brief (if overly patronizing and insensitive) summary of what bothered me about HBO’s new show: Girls.

I didn’t know much about it going in, other than I was pretty excited. Anyone who’s been watching Game of Thrones has probably seen a trailer for it in the last month, and the pilot finally aired last Sunday. And a week out the critical cycle is well underway, with initial praise followed by some (mild?) backlash, followed by a breakdown of the pilot’s cultural shortcomings (rather than its comedic or narrative ones). Continue reading this post…

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Thursday Art Walk

by Ethan Gach April 19, 2012
Thumbnail image for Thursday Art Walk

“Whaam!” (1963) by Roy Fox Lichtenstein.

9 comments Read the full article →

Intellectual Art, Popular Media, and Getting Away from Aesthetic Subjectivity

by Ethan Gach April 18, 2012
Thumbnail image for Intellectual Art, Popular Media, and Getting Away from Aesthetic Subjectivity

In the May 2012 issue of the Atlantic, writer Taylor Clark has an excellent profile of videogame developer Jonathan Blow. He’s misanthropic, severely thoughtful, and somewhat abrasive. But he’s also a brilliant creator and a near perfect example of what Clark thinks the medium needs more of: developers willing to make smart videogames. Because for Clark the medium is currently an “artistic backwater” that produces only a few truly artful videogames in a sea teeming with “dumb” ones. Many think that Clark is ...

104 comments Read the full article →

How Not to Discuss Whether We Need Stories

by Ethan Gach April 3, 2012
Thumbnail image for How Not to Discuss Whether We Need Stories

“Do we need stories?” asks Tim Parks. An interesting question. And an important one. But not a matter easily resolved within the confines of a few tweets, a couple Facebook updates, or an entire blog post (even one at the respected New York Review of Books). That’s obvious though, right? So why Does Parks appear attempting just that? And what does he have to show for it?

9 comments Read the full article →

A New Ending Couldn’t Destroy Mass Effect’s Artistic Integrity

by Ethan Gach March 22, 2012
Thumbnail image for A New Ending Couldn’t Destroy Mass Effect’s Artistic Integrity

[Note: This is a companion piece to something I wrote earlier this week on the same subject but from a different point of view.  In addition, while there are no spoilers per say, the way I talk about and characterize Mass Effect 3's ending in the abstract might make it better for people who want to approach the end of the game with no preconceptions to pass for now.  For anyone who wants background on the game, or the controversy over the ...

45 comments Read the full article →

Don’t Fear Me

by Ethan Gach March 20, 2012
Thumbnail image for Don’t Fear Me

I won’t go into any of the details surrounding the shooting of Trayvon Martin.  First of all because many of them are in dispute, but more importantly because none of them really matter, or at least shouldn’t. The reality of the matter is that in Florida the law will protect you if you gun someone down because you felt “reasonably” afraid for your life.

229 comments Read the full article →

A Peculiar Kind of Reasoning

by Ethan Gach March 6, 2012

I’ve been MIA recently, most due to some other projects I’ve been working on.  But I’ll have some deeper thoughts on the following later on…right after I’ve succeeded in picking my jaw back up from off the floor. From a speech Eric Holder delivered at Northwestern University yesterday (emphasis mine):

13 comments Read the full article →

In Which I Discuss Jonathan Franzen’s Remarks at Length

by Ethan Gach January 31, 2012

Speaking recently at the Hay Festival in Cartagena, Colombia, American novelist, Jonathan Franzen, attacked what he identifies as the impermanence of ebooks.  His following remarks are what Andrew Sullivan recently dismissed as “Wieseltierian piffle,”

21 comments Read the full article →

Something’s Rotten in the State of Our Union

by Ethan Gach January 27, 2012

Many have debated the President’s remarks from last Tuesday night’s State of the Union speech.  E.D. Kain thought it was very successful, providing the American audience with a “rousing speech about the American dream, the American promise–the indispensable nation that is us…”  Andrew Sullivan was disappointed because the speech didn’t lay out a clear vision for fundamental tax reform.  Jason Kuznicki felt the President’s remarks reeked of fascism.  And Tod Kelly argued that commentators were overlooking the perceptions and feelings of the ...

12 comments Read the full article →

2012 Oscar Nominations Have Been Announced

by Ethan Gach January 24, 2012

I’m sad to say that I haven’t had a chance to see a majority of the films listed here.  Especially over this past year, I’ve taken to spending my money on seeing movies that are absolutely terrible (like, for instance, Real Steel: a movie so ridculous I left the theater with eyes full of tears from laughing so hard). Controverseys are starting to bubble

22 comments Read the full article →

Anarchy, State, and Batman

by Ethan Gach January 19, 2012

The discussion between Taylor Marvin, Erik Kain, and Jamelle Bouie about Nolan’s Batman films is already superb.  I’m not sure how much I can add to the conversation, but as a long time Batman fan I can’t resist.  But first, a recap. At issue is how exactly Nolan positions Batman within the context of Gotham and its ongoing urban decay.   Is Batman working outside of civil society?  Is he subverting it?  Or simply responding to a system that is already in ...

131 comments Read the full article →

Sullivan, Obama, and Elections

by Ethan Gach January 18, 2012

Let me get this out of the way first.  I like Andrew Sullivan, appreciate a lot of the work he produces, and can cite the Dish as an enormous triumph in blogging that is both insightful and entertaining.  Now then, with that praise entered into the official record, onto the controversy. Sullivan has already gotten a lot of pushback for his recent Newsweek cover story.  Yesterday, Conor Friedersdorf went on to criticize the piece, “Why are Obama’s Critics so Dumb?” at length, ...

59 comments Read the full article →

How Much Better is the United States?

by Ethan Gach January 11, 2012

A week or so ago, Tom Van Dyke linked to this NYT piece exploring Europe’s economic troubles.  The article, by Adam Davidson, posited that the Eurozone suffers from economic woes that go deeper than just the recent crisis, and notes how much better the U.S. fairs when compared to its European counterparts in terms of per capita GDP. Of course, as both a Europhile and big fan of Davidson’s work over at Planet Money, I had to look deeper into ...

16 comments Read the full article →

When the Fourth Estate Fails

by Ethan Gach January 9, 2012

Reading the article by Eric Schmitt that ran in last Sunday’s New York Times under the headline, “Lull in Strikes by U.S. Drones Aids Militants in Pakistan,” one gets a sense of just how much unipolar imperialism has become embedded in mainstream American culture. If nothing else, the just over 1,200 word piece demonstrates why the American Press is not a Fourth Estate, but rather a Fourth Branch of government.  To the degree that it is independent, the press is ...

99 comments Read the full article →

What’s In A Label

by Ethan Gach January 3, 2012

Andrew Sullivan calls out Jonathan Chait for arguing that libertarianism is inextricably linked to racism.  Chait’s view, in a nutshell, is that in practice, libertarianism is a gateway doctrine to racism: “I am sure Paul’s motives derive from ideological fervor rather than a conscious desire to oppress minorities. But the relationship between the abstract principles of his worldview and the ugly racism with which it has so frequently been expressed is hardly coincidental.” Sullivan fires back and draws a distinction between private ...

24 comments Read the full article →

“Kicking, squealing Gucci little piggy”

by Ethan Gach December 20, 2011

  I think meat tastes great.  I love me some buffalo smothered chicken wings.  It wouldn’t be Thanksgiving without Turkey.  I reside near a Bobby’s Burger Palace, and live in constant fear of the tastiness made to order inside.  The only real meatballs are made with beef, and there is a reason why steak, when cooked right, only needs potatoes to become a meal in itself.  The only thing better than a ham sandwich is a pulled pork sandwich, and the only thing ...

145 comments Read the full article →

“Nonsense!”

by Ethan Gach December 16, 2011

Christopher Hitchens died yesterday.  Vanity Fair broke the news and any number of publications are running obituaries at the moment.  For myself, I can only say that one of my biggest regrets is never having seen him speak in person.  He was a brilliant debater and uniquely entertaining and an inspiring essayist.  I daresay that I have seen nearly all of his public appearances, interviews, and discussions, at one time or another, via Youtube and Vimeo.  Why I was so compelled ...

17 comments Read the full article →